(Indispensable: When Leaders Really Matter)

The paper will be five written pages in length and include all of the five sections below (A through E). The paper will include a title page (per APA format), which will not count as a one of the five required pages. The paper should use the format below for headings and written in paragraph form (except for part A). The paper should be free of grammatical and spelling errors and exhibit quality written scholarship commensurate with graduate standards.
A. Bibliographical (per APA format)
B. Author’s Credential (1-3 sentences)
C. Thesis (The Main Proposition Stated in the book; 1-3 sentences)
D. Body (Thesis Development) – Did the author achieve the stated purpose? Inspect
each section of the text to see how the thesis is (or is not) developed. If the author makes supported and logical progress advancing the thesis – cite in review.
Possible question in the body (Do not include all of the questions in your paper, instead be deliberate and expound on your findings):
• Is there an adequate, consistent development of the author’s thesis? Why or why not?
• What is the author’s purpose? Does the author accomplish the purpose? If so, how? If not, why not?
• Does the author approach the subject with any biases? Do they influence the conclusions?
• Does the author adequately consider and refute opposing viewpoints?
• Is the thesis sound but marred by a flawed procedure?
E. Finally, a summary (1-2 paragraphs) that includes: How does this text differ from
other treatments of the same subject matter? What is unique and valuable about this approach as opposed to the others? Would the reviewer recommend this text above others? Why or why not?